Blueprint:
s-Numbers of Bounded Linear Operators
between Banach Spaces

3.3 Gelfand numbers \(c_n\)

Definition 3.5 Gelfand number
#

For \(S \in \mathcal{L}(X, Y)\) and \(n \in \mathbb {N}_0\),

\[ c_n(S) := \inf \bigl\{ \| S \restriction _M\| : M \subseteq X \text{ closed subspace, } \operatorname {codim} M \le n \bigr\} . \]
Theorem 3.6

Let \(\mathbb {K}\) be a non-trivially normed field and \(X, Y\) normed spaces over \(\mathbb {K}\). Then the Gelfand numbers \(c = (c_n)_n\) form a strict s-number sequence: they satisfy (S1)–(S5) and the strengthening (S5\('\)).

Proof

The development is dual to the Kolmogorov one (Theorem 3.8) under the domain \(\leftrightarrow \) codomain swap: where the Kolmogorov numbers push \(S\) down a quotient projection \(\pi _V : Y \to Y/V\) for a small \(V \subseteq Y\), the Gelfand numbers restrict \(S\) along the inclusion \(\iota _M : M \hookrightarrow X\) for a subspace \(M \subseteq X\) of small codimension. With \(M = X\) one gets \(c_0(S) = \| S\| \); (S2) is the triangle inequality applied to \((S+T) \circ \iota _M\). For the ideal property (S3), following [ 8 , § 2.4 ] , take admissible \(M\) for \(S\) and pass to \(M' := A^{-1}(M)\): it is closed, its codimension is at most that of \(M\) by the first isomorphism theorem applied to \(\pi _M \circ A\), and \(\| BSA(w)\| \le \| B\| \, \| S \circ \iota _M\| \, \| A\| \, \| w\| \) for \(w \in M'\). For (S4) take \(M := \ker S\), which is closed with \(\operatorname {codim} M = \operatorname {rank} S \le n\) and \(S \circ \iota _M = 0\). For (S5\('\)), the inclusion \(\iota _M\) is an isometry, so the identity restricted to any nontrivial \(M\) has norm \(1\), and \(\operatorname {codim} M \le n {\lt} \dim X\) forces \(M \neq \{ 0\} \). Formalised in Gelfand.lean.

The argument needs only a non-trivially normed scalar field \(\mathbb {K}\); unlike its Kolmogorov dual (Theorem 3.8) it requires neither completeness of \(\mathbb {K}\) nor Riesz’s lemma.